Columbus Approves NWSL Team Bid Amid Heated Debate Over McCoy Park Future
By Nexio News | June 10, 2024
COLUMBUS, Ohio — City leaders have narrowly approved a plan to bring a National Women’s Soccer League (NWSL) team to Columbus, but not without fierce debate over the fate of a beloved neighborhood park.
After a tense city council meeting Monday night, officials voted 5-3 to advance the proposal, which includes turning McCoy Park into a training facility for the potential expansion team. The decision came with strict conditions to address community concerns about losing green space in an underserved area.
A Contentious Compromise
The plan, backed by the Haslam Sports Group—owners of the Columbus Crew—and local investors, initially sparked backlash when it proposed converting McCoy Park into a private training complex. Critics argued the move would strip children and families of a vital recreational area.
To ease tensions, the amended agreement requires the mayor’s office to identify and break ground on a replacement park within two months if the NWSL bid succeeds. The Haslam group must also contribute $3 million to the project and guarantee public access to parts of the facility.
“No plans, no site, then no money,” warned City Council President Shannon Hardin. “Our goal is to make sure the administration delivers for neighbors as quickly as it did for these companies.”
Community Voices Clash
The hours-long meeting saw passionate arguments from both sides. Opponents called the deal a giveaway to wealthy investors.
“Voting yes gives away a public park to billionaires,” said Liz Reed, a resident opposed to the plan.
Supporters, however, emphasized the economic and cultural benefits of bringing professional women’s soccer to the city.
“This is going to benefit women,” said Mark Wise, a local advocate. “It’s a chance to invest in female athletes the way we have for men’s sports.”
Economic Promise vs. Park Preservation
Mayor Andrew Ginther defended the plan, calling it a “win-win” that balances economic growth with community needs. The city estimates the NWSL team could generate $118 million in tax revenue over 30 years while creating hundreds of jobs.
“We’re committed to finding another green space for the southwest side,” Ginther said. “This isn’t an either-or situation—it’s a way for Columbus to lead.”
Yet critics remain skeptical. Derek Bergman, a vocal opponent, accused the council of prioritizing corporate interests over families. “They’re still willing to rip a park away from kids,” he said.
What Comes Next?
The Haslam Sports Group, partnering with Nationwide and local physicians Christine and Pete Edwards, praised the council’s decision, calling it a step toward securing the NWSL’s 18th franchise by 2028.
Franklin County officials are still negotiating additional agreements, but the amended legislation aims to ensure the city doesn’t sacrifice public resources for the deal.
As Columbus moves forward with its bid, the debate over McCoy Park underscores a larger question: Can cities foster major-league sports growth without leaving communities behind?
For now, the answer rests on whether leaders can deliver on their promises—both to the NWSL and to the families who call Columbus home.
— Reported by Nexio News
